---
title: Metal seed phrase backup: what the stress tests showed
url: https://bitcoinseedbook.com/metal-seed-backups/
description: Six rounds of public fire, acid and crush tests on metal seed backups. Which designs lost words, which kept them, and how to stamp your own in steel.
published: 2026-05-28
updated: 2026-05-28
section: E. Physical storage
tags: Cold Storage
---

# Metal seed phrase backup: what the stress tests showed

Paper burns in a house fire and stainless steel doesn't. That is the case for a metal seed phrase backup. Most metal backups are devices, though, and devices fail in ways a sheet of steel can't: slots warp, tiles fall out, screws seize, cases melt. The best public record of which designs kept the words readable comes from one person with a torch.

## The tests

Jameson Lopp ran six rounds of stress tests on commercial and DIY metal backups between July 2018 and August 2022, and published each round on his blog. By August 2022 he put the count at 70 devices. His review site grades each one A to F for heat, corrosion and crush, and he is plain that the grading is his own judgement: no data loss earns an A, catastrophic loss an F.

In the later rounds each device went through the same three tests:

1. **Heat.** A propane torch at about 2,000°F (1,093°C) for 10 minutes, then straight into a bucket of water, the way a fire hose would cool it. In the first round he noted that the average house fire runs around 1,100°F, so the torch is roughly double the common case.
2. **Corrosion.** A soak in 16% muriatic (hydrochloric) acid for 12 hours or until the bubbling stops. He says himself that acid is probably not your threat. It is there to separate the devices.
3. **Crush.** A 20-ton hydraulic press, then a check of whether the data can still be read.

These are one man's bench tests. We know of no other public series that ran this long, and the failures repeat often enough to read as patterns.

## What failed

**Tiles in rails.** Devices that hold loose letter tiles in a slotted tray did worst. In the first round both rail devices tested lost letters in the heat test, because the tray warped, and by the time Lopp pried them open after the press "pretty much all of the letters had fallen out." A tablet-style tile holder failed the same way in Round III. Its redesign, with a slot per letter and 13 screws a side, still lost tiles in the heat test. Lopp's summary of the type: "Like the vast majority of tile-in-rail based devices, it tends not to do well with crushing because the rails get warped, space is created, and tiles fall out."

**Aluminium.** Aluminium melts at 660°C (1,221°F), only a little above the average house-fire figure Lopp quotes. Two devices in Round III with aluminium bodies collapsed in the heat test, one of them into "a bunch of slag."

**Thin plates.** A 1.8 mm stainless tag lost part of its body to the acid and then broke when bent with two pairs of pliers. A paper-thin copper sheet, written on with a pen, appeared to melt at one edge, and the lightly pressed words there became nearly illegible.

**Shallow marks and printed templates.** Hand-engraved words on one plate were "completely lost at the point of heat application" while the stamped words beside them survived. Light factory etching faded. Templates printed in ink burned off, which left the dots with nothing to decode them against.

**Fasteners.** Screws melted, dissolved in acid, stripped, or seized after the plates expanded and shrank. The data inside usually survives; getting at it may take a machine shop.

## What survived

Solid stainless steel or titanium plates with the data center-punched (a dot per letter on a printed grid), stamped (letter punches and a hammer) or etched by electrolysis made up most of the A grades. Punching and stamping beat tiles, with one qualification: the tiles that lost were the ones held in rails. A capsule that holds letter tiles inside a sealed steel tube got A-: the data stayed intact, but the press bent the tube enough that getting the tiles out became the problem.

Lopp's treatise of August 2022 lists what the best devices share:

- stainless steel or titanium
- small but thick
- one solid piece of metal
- center-punched or electrolysis-etched data
- the decoding template marked on the device as deeply as the data

He recommends austenitic stainless, grade 316 or 316L for corrosion resistance, and gives 304 a melting range of 1,400–1,450°C and 316 a range of 1,375–1,400°C. For thickness he suggests at least 5 mm, preferably over 1 cm, because long thin plates flex.

On how to mark the metal, he found center punching the easiest and stamping the most miserable: missed blows, light strikes, double strikes, and letters stamped the wrong way round. Stamped data still survived the tests; it is just hard to do well.

## Do it yourself

A DIY backup leaves no shipping record saying you bought a seed backup. Lopp tested four DIY designs, and all four graded A or A-. One was a stack of stainless fender washers on a stainless bolt with an acorn cap nut, all from a hardware store. It came through the 20-ton press better than he expected. He was still wary of any design with loose pieces that can fall out of order.

### What you need

- Stainless steel stock: a plate, as thick as you can stamp (Lopp's 5 mm is the target), or fender washers. 316 if you can get it. No aluminium, brass or copper.
- A letter-and-number stamp set, or a center punch and a grid you mark on the plate first.
- A hammer (steel, not rubber; Lopp tried rubber and got faint stamps) and a steel block to strike on.
- For washers: a stainless bolt and an acorn cap nut that fit them.
- Scrap steel to practise on.

### What to stamp

BIP-39 makes this short. The standard's wordlist is built "in such a way that it's enough to type the first four letters to unambiguously identify the word", and we checked the English list: all 2,048 words have a different first four letters. Words of three letters you stamp whole. So a 24-word seed is 96 characters at most, plus the word numbers.

Number every word. On a loose tile or washer, the number is what puts it back in order; Lopp's rule is one word per tile with its number on it. Twenty-four shuffled words with no numbers can be arranged in 24! ways, about 6.2 × 10²³.

### Procedure

1. Practise on scrap. Stamp the public example, `pizza educate fat kiss domain venue …` (this phrase is public: never use it for real funds), as `PIZZ EDUC FAT KISS DOMA VENU`, until your strikes are even.
2. Clamp the plate or washer to the block so it can't bounce. A small plate that moves under the hammer was one of Lopp's complaints.
3. Check which way the letter faces before every blow. Then hit once, hard and square. A second blow on a letter stamp is how you get a doubled letter.
4. Stamp the word number, then the four letters, word by word in order. On washers, one word per side.
5. Read the result back against the [BIP-39 wordlist](https://bitcoinseedbook.com/en-bip39/) and confirm the wallet restores from it. [Test a seed backup](https://bitcoinseedbook.com/test-a-seed-backup/) covers the restore.
6. Destroy the practice pieces and any paper you worked from.

## Letters or cipher numbers

You can stamp the cipher numbers from this site instead of letters. Every number in our [ciphers](https://bitcoinseedbook.com/cyphers/) is four digits, from 5432 to 7479, so the length is the same and you need ten stamps instead of 26. A plate of numbers also doesn't read as a seed phrase from across the room.

The cost is error tolerance. Lopp points out that if one character of a four-letter word becomes unreadable, there are maybe two words it could be. Lose one digit of a number and it could be up to ten. Our cipher numbers narrow that a little, since anything outside 5432–7479 is impossible, and the seed's checksum will usually catch a wrong guess. Stamp deep either way.

**Hiding is not encrypting.** The ciphers are public and a seed phrase carries its own checksum, so a list someone recognises as a seed can be tried against every cipher in minutes. A steel plate of numbers survives a fire. It doesn't survive someone who knows what it is. Add a [BIP-39 passphrase](https://bitcoinseedbook.com/bip39-passphrase-25th-word/) to the wallet and keep it somewhere else.

## Where it goes

A metal backup handles fire and flood for one copy. It does nothing about theft, and a steel plate is easy to recognise. Where to keep it: [seed phrase storage](https://bitcoinseedbook.com/seed-phrase-storage/) and [hide a seed in the house](https://bitcoinseedbook.com/hide-a-seed-in-the-house/). More than one copy: [split a seed across places](https://bitcoinseedbook.com/split-a-seed-across-places/). Staying with paper: [paper seed backups that last](https://bitcoinseedbook.com/paper-seed-backups-that-last/).

*We will never ask for a seed word or a passphrase. Never type one into this site or any tool it links to.*

## Sources

- Jameson Lopp, [Metal Bitcoin Seed Storage Reviews](https://jlopp.github.io/metal-bitcoin-storage-reviews/): per-device heat, corrosion and crush grades, and the [stress test methodology](https://jlopp.github.io/metal-bitcoin-storage-reviews/how): 2,000°F for 10 minutes and a water quench, 16% muriatic acid for 12 hours, 20-ton press, the A–F grading.
- Jameson Lopp, the six rounds: [Round I](https://blog.lopp.net/metal-bitcoin-seed-storage-stress-test/) (July 2018: rail devices losing letters, engraved versus stamped, the 1,100°F house-fire figure), [Part II](https://blog.lopp.net/metal-bitcoin-seed-storage-stress-test-part-ii/) (May 2019), [Round III](https://blog.lopp.net/metal-bitcoin-seed-storage-stress-test-round-iii/) (December 2019: aluminium bodies, the tile tablet), [Round IV](https://blog.lopp.net/metal-bitcoin-seed-storage-stress-test-iv/) (August 2020: the hardware-store washer stack), [Round V](https://blog.lopp.net/metal-bitcoin-seed-storage-stress-tests-round-v/) (November 2021), [Round VI](https://blog.lopp.net/metal-bitcoin-seed-storage-stress-tests-round-vi/) (August 2022: thin tag, copper sheet, seized fasteners, stamping complaints).
- Jameson Lopp, [A Treatise on Bitcoin Seed Backup Device Design](https://blog.lopp.net/a-treatise-on-bitcoin-seed-backup-device-design/), August 2022: 70 devices, materials and stainless grades, thickness, marking methods, tile combinatorics, letters versus line numbers, deep templates.
- Royal Society of Chemistry, [Aluminium](https://periodic-table.rsc.org/element/13/aluminium): melting point 660.323°C.
- [BIP-39](https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0039.mediawiki) and its [English wordlist](https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0039/english.txt): the first-four-letters property.
